Polkey v Dayton Services [1987] IRLR 503

Key Point

  • A dismissal will be procedurally unfair where an employee demonstrates that the employer failed to follow a fair procedure before dismissal.
  • However, the court established the “no difference rule”: where a tribunal finds that dismissal would have been inevitable even if the correct procedure had been followed, compensation can be reduced to reflect that (the “Polkey reduction”).

Facts

  • A van driver with four years’ service was summoned to his manager’s office and told out of the blue that he was being made redundant.
  • No warning was given, no consultation was carried out, and no procedure of any kind was followed.
  • The employer’s redundancy was genuine, the business had declining needs, but the manner of dismissal was procedurally unfair.

Issue

  • Can a dismissal be found fair despite a complete failure to follow proper procedure, on the basis that following procedure would have made no difference to the outcome?

Held (House of Lords)

  • The House of Lords allowed the employee’s appeal.
  • Procedure must be followed unless it would have been “utterly useless” or futile to do so.
  • The Industrial Tribunal had erred in finding the dismissal fair simply because redundancy was inevitable. Procedural fairness is not rendered irrelevant by the substantive merits of the employer’s decision.
  • However, where a tribunal concludes that following proper procedure would have made no difference to the outcome, it may reduce compensation (the “Polkey reduction”) to reflect the chance that the employee would have been dismissed anyway. In this case compensation could be reduced to zero.

Lord Mackay of Clashfern

  • ‘This appeal raises an important question in the law of unfair dismissal. Where an Industrial Tribunal has found that the reason for an applicant’s dismissal was a reason of a kind such as could justify the dismissal and has found that there has been a failure to consult or warn the applicant in accordance with the code of practice, should the Tribunal consider whether, if the employee had been consulted or warned before dismissal was decided upon, he would nevertheless have been dismissed?…’ [3]
  • (At [11], Quoting Browne-Wilkinson J in British Labour Pump [1979] IRLR 94):
    • ‘The weight to be attached to such procedural failure should depend upon the circumstances known to the employer at the time of dismissal, not on the actual consequence of such failure. Thus in the case of a failure to give an opportunity to explain, except in the rare case where a reasonable employer could properly take the view on the facts known to him at the time of dismissal that no explanation or mitigation could alter his decision to dismiss, an Industrial Tribunal would be likely to hold that the lack of “equity” inherent in the failure would render the dismissal unfair. But there may be cases where the offence is so heinous and the facts so manifestly clear that a reasonable employer could, on the facts known to him at the time of dismissal, take the view that whatever explanation the employee advanced it would make no difference… [in those circumstances] compensation would be reduced to nil.’
  • ‘I gratefully adopt that analysis.’ [12]

Commentary

  • The most practically significant aspect of the case is the compensation principle it establishes – which is known as the “Polkey reduction”.
  • PQ point: compensation can be reduced where the employer shows that a fair procedure would have been utterly futile, or that it would have made no difference to the outcome of dismissal.

Ace your exams with premium notes, model answers & PQ guides

Visit the Shop
SourceFeedback